November 11, 2026

$91 to $168 by 2031? Youngstown’s proposed sewer hikes, explained

Rusted sewer inlet and manhole in a sidewalk

Photo: WFMJ

$91 to $168 by 2031. You've seen that number. Let's be precise about what it actually is.

That is a PROPOSED sewer charge. It is not approved, and it is not your drinking-water rate. An average Youngstown wastewater customer uses about 500 cubic feet a month and currently pays $87.20. Under the 5% increases council already approved, that would be $91.56 in 2027. Under the new 14% plan, the figures are about $99 in 2027, then about $113, $129, $147, and about $168 in 2031.

If council goes along, an average sewer bill nearly doubles in five years: $1,046.40 a year now, about $2,015 in 2031.

Why? A U.S. EPA consent decree from 2002 requires Youngstown to cut contaminated overflows into the Mahoning River and Mill Creek. The original order was $310 million in work, negotiated down to $160 million in 2014, and now estimated at $404 million in a city-commissioned Arcadis study. The deadline is Sept. 29, 2032. Annual debt service is $5 million now and jumps to $27 million a year starting in 2032, for 20 years. Officials and the consultant have said that without the 14% hikes, Ohio may not approve the loans, and the city could default on the decree.

That is the city's case. It is not a done deal.

The request is up for discussion at the Nov. 17 meeting. 4th Ward Councilman Mike Ray said the increases may be "a reality," but he wants savings found first and asked whether overtime is "need or is it greed." 3rd Ward Councilwoman Samantha Turner called 14% a "hard sell."

And this is not the only hit coming. A separate drinking-water increase is expected in January because the Mahoning Valley Sanitary District is raising the bulk rate it charges the city. Water Commissioner Harry L. Johnson III said the pass-through figure was not finalized, with preliminary talk of a double-digit increase in January and a smaller one in 2028. The last city water-rate increase was in 2014.

Our take: the system needs work. Nobody serious is arguing sewage should keep overflowing into the river. But $404 million is a long way from the $160 million they negotiated in 2014, and residents are being told to cover the difference at 14% a year. In our opinion, council should show the cuts, the grants, and the math in public BEFORE anybody rubber-stamps this. That's our opinion, not a finding.

Watch Nov. 17. This one will show up in the mailbox.

The people who keep the lights on

Our Sponsors

Car CultureSymons Water & ConstructionBubble TechMenchie's Boardman
Become a Sponsor