November 6, 2026

A downtown medical center, a dumpster, and a $300,000 lawsuit

Downtown West Federal Street commercial building with a covered facade and an empty storefront

Photo: WFMJ

A downtown developer has sued the City of Youngstown for more than $300,000. According to the lawsuit, the dispute centers on dumpster placement outside a West Federal Street property.

Read that again. Dumpster placement.

We're going to be clear up front: this is a lawsuit. It is not a verdict. Everything that follows is what the complaint alleges, unless we say otherwise.

The suit was filed by Cleveland attorney Jay Crook on behalf of Proffessor Enterprises LLC. It names the city and Chuck Shasho, identified in the lawsuit as Youngstown's public works director, as defendants. The company is asking for more than $75,000 in actual damages and more than $225,000 in punitive damages.

County and state records show Jantz Clinkscale assigned the West Federal Street property to that LLC in 2021 and later incorporated a nonprofit, Thee Birthright USA, to operate an "Infant and Maternal Family Medical Arts Center" there. The building is still empty. The lawsuit says the renovations were never finished.

Here is the story the complaint tells. Clinkscale needed a generator and a dumpster for the work. He says he had approvals, the dumpster arrived in August 2024, and the city then blocked, tagged, and hauled it off on March 12, 2025. The suit says all renovation work stopped three days later. It claims the city has an "informal policy" giving Shasho permitting authority "which go outside the law."

The lawsuit also alleges this got personal after a separate $500 planning-commission fee that Shasho later said was not required. Clinkscale asked for a refund, did not get one, and got into it with Shasho at the public works office, according to the complaint. The filing attributes quotes to that exchange. We were not in the room.

He claims he lost $420,000 in expected revenue from dentist and OB-GYN leases that were never fulfilled, at least $130,000 more in potential commercial revenue, and that he had already spent $20,000 on the building. The complaint says the city issued a notice of violation and $1,600 in assessments in October 2026, which he says he cannot fix without a dumpster.

Crook said his office does not comment on ongoing litigation. The city has not publicly answered the allegations. We do not have the city's side of this, and we are not going to invent one.

Our take: we are not the court. In our opinion, the public still deserves a straight answer from City Hall. Did a medical project in downtown Youngstown really stall out over a dumpster? If not, what happened? That's a fair question. It is not a finding of fact.

The people who keep the lights on

Our Sponsors

Car CultureSymons Water & ConstructionBubble TechMenchie's Boardman
Become a Sponsor